Judge: Forest Service Not Liable For Hayman Fire
Judge: Forest Service Not Liable For Hayman Fire
25 November 2008
published by www.thedenverchannel.com
USA — The Forest Service is not liable for Colorado’s largest and most destructive wildfire, a federal judge presiding over a civil case ruled Tuesday.
The Hayman Fire blackened 138,000 acres, destroyed 133 homes and forced more than 8,000 people to evacuate.
State Farm and other insurance companies had sued the Forest Service, seeking to cover the $7 million-plus they paid out in claims from the 2002 Hayman Fire. They argued that the Forest Service was negligent and that Terry Barton, a Forest Service employee, was not properly trained and also negligent in the way she tried to suppress the fire.
Chief U.S. District Judge Wiley Daniel on Tuesday said the Forest Service is not negligent and the Forest Service does not owe the insurance company money.
The judge ruled in favor of the government saying Terry Barton was not acting in the scope of her employment when she started the fire and, essentially, the Forest Service did everything possible to extinguish the fire, said U.S. Attorney spokesman Jeff Dorschner.
The insurance companies had argued that if Barton had been properly trained as a Forest Service employee and known what to do when the fire broke out, it wouldn’t have gotten so far out of control.
Barton pleaded guilty to state and federal arson charges and served six years in prison. She was released in June.
Barton was tasked with the job of enforcing the fire ban in the Pike National Forest when she said she burned a letter in a campfire ring. She said she thought the fire was out when she drove away. It was only later, when she was driving by the site, that she realized that the flames had escaped and grown out of control, she said.Previous Stories:
- September 12, 2008: Terry Barton: I Was Emotionally Amiss
- September 12, 2008: Testimony: Burned Letter Didn’t Start Hayman Wildfire
- September 11, 2008: Fire Starter Subpoenaed To Court
- September 9, 2008: Agent Disputes Official Version Of Hayman Fire
- September 9, 2008: Hayman Fire Sparks Federal Lawsuit
- July 23, 2008: More Counties Enact Burn Bans
- June 2, 2008: Hayman Firestarter Free After Nearly 6 Years In Prison
- April 8, 2008: 130,000 Seedlings To Be Planted In Hayman Burn Area
- March 27, 2008: Hayman Firestarter Won’t Spend Any Prison Time In Colo.
- June 8, 2007: Witnesses Remember Hayman Fire 5 Years Later
- April 4, 2007: Seedlings To Sprout Life In Hayman Fire Area
- February 27, 2007: Hayman Firestarter May Get New Trial
- July 14, 2006: Terry Barton Sentencing Delayed
- July 11, 2006: Highway Hit Hardest By Flood In Hayman Area
- July 9, 2006: Floods In Hayman Burn Area Prompt Disaster Declaration
- October 11, 2005: Court Won’t Hear Appeal In Hayman Fire Case
- December 23, 2004: ‘I Made A Mistake,’ Hayman Firestarter Tells 7NEWS
- December 16, 2004: Prison Sentence Tossed Out For Hayman Firestarter
- June 8, 2004: Mountain Community Anxious On Anniversary Of Hayman Fire
- March 9, 2004: Woman Who Started Hayman Fire Back In Court