USA-Smoke’s surprising secret
(byRebecca Lindsey, 5 January 2004,Earth Observatory)
When crops, rangeland, and managed forests come down with diseases, farmers and ranchers all over the world sometimes choose to burn the diseased fields in an attempt to sterilize the area, giving little thought to the smoke that can spread hundreds of miles away. A high school student working on a back yard science project now has pretty clear evidence that such fires may not kill everything we thought. In samples of the smoke from massive fires in Central America that reached Texas in the spring of 2002, she found living fungal spores that were perfectly able to start new colonies. This surprising discovery from a young, amateur scientist has the potential to change the prevailing wisdom on the benefits of burning diseased crops or timber.
[Sarah Mims, a teenager from Seguin, Texas, is studying the smoke and dust that arrive over her hometown from thousands of miles away. By her senior year in high school, she had already made some surprisingdiscoveries.]
When Sarah Mims discovered that smoke drifting across the Gulf of Mexico from fires in Central America was bringing fungal spores to the air around her home Seguin, Texas, she was definitely surprised. When Mims set out microscope slides and a continuous-operation air filter on a deer stand in her family’s yard, she expected to get a collection of dust samples that she could check for the presence of fungus and bacteria.
Sarah Mims, a teenager from Seguin, Texas, is studying the smoke and dust that arrive over her hometown from thousands of miles away. By her senior year in high school, she had already made some surprising discoveries.
I was initially just planning to follow up on my project from the previous summer, says Mims. In 2001, when she was in the 10th grade, Mims had decided to study the aerosols in her hometown. When most people think of aerosols, they think of hairspray or deodorant. But aerosols can be any small liquid or solid particle suspended in the air, including sea salt, volcanic ash, smoke, and dust. Mims had read that dust from the Sahara Desert, more than 4,000 kilometers away in North Africa, could be blown all the way over the Atlantic Ocean to North and South America. In the summer of 2001 numerous dust events in Florida and Texas created colorful sunsets and layered a thin blanket of dust on car windshields. Of course, Texas itself can be a dusty place. I wanted to find out whether the dust was local, or whether some of it could be coming from the Sahara, says Mims.
Mims analyzed the particles caught on her microscope slides using a cross-polarized light source that makes dust particles made out of quartza characteristic of Saharan dustglitter with all the colors of the rainbow. Since the local dust, from a kind of soil called caliche that is common in South Texas, doesnt change color under polarized light, Mims knew that the sparkling, shimmering dust she had collected wasnt from Texas. Her description of the dust particles carries a sense of wonder and appreciation for natures magic that often seems missing from the world of grown-up, professional science. They were really pretty, she says, like rainbows. Mims also measured the size of the particles and took pictures of them, which she compared to pictures of Saharan Dust particles that she found in books. They looked just alike, she said.
As her final piece of evidence, Mims used satellite observations of aerosols from the Sea-viewing Wide Field-of-View Sensor (SeaWiFS), the Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS), and the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR), combined with models of the atmosphere from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration that showed the back trajectory of the air that was sitting over Texas on the days her samples and the satellite images were capturedin other words, where the air had been before it got to Texas. On the days when her filters were dirtiest and her microscope slides were covered with the most particles, the satellite images showed lots of aerosols over the region, and the back trajectory maps showed the air was coming from North Africa. Putting all these pieces together, says Mims, It was obvious that the dust was SaharanDust.
A Smoky Surprise
Since disease-causing bacteria and fungi have been known to hitch a ride across the Atlantic on Saharan Dust particles (they have probably played a role in the decline of Caribbean coral reefs over the past two decades), Mims decided to see whether she might be able to find bacteria or fungal spores along with dust from Asian deserts that sometimes reaches Texas in the spring. In the spring of 2002, she set out her microscope slides along with Petrifilmsstrips of gel and nutrients that can be used to grow microorganisms like bacteria and mold.
The strips come dry, and you have to squirt them with water before you expose them to the air. Once you set them out in the air for 15 minutes, you cover them up with a clear sheet of plastic, and after a few days, if you caught anything, youll see stuff starting to grow, saysMims.
The technique was a success. Within a few days, Mims gel strips were practically a jungle of different colored splotches, each one a separate fungal colony. Large numbers of spores were also visible on the microscope slides she had exposed to the air almost every day between April 25 and May 17. There was just one problem, at least from her Asian-dust-carrying-microbes hypothesis: the slides didnt show any Asian dust!
There were a lot of fungal spores that I could identify on the slides, says Mims,even at the beginning of the period. But there really wasnt much dust. What she did see on the slides was a lot of black carbon particles, in other words, soot. To help solve the puzzle, Mims turned to satellite images. Observations from the Sea-viewing Wide Field-of-View Sensor (SeaWiFS) during that time showed huge plumes of smoke from forest fires in southern Mexico and Central America crossing the Gulf of Mexico and blowing over Texas. Could the Central American smoke be bringing the fungal spores with it?
I counted the number of spores and the number of carbon particles on the slides, explains Mims. If the spores were coming from fungus that lived in our area, then there shouldnt be any relationship between the amount of black carbon soot and the number of fungal spores.
Instead what Mims found was that when the number or carbon particles went up, the number of certain kinds of sporesbut not all of themwent up, too. This is exactly what you would expect to see if some of the spores came from local sources and some came along with the smoke. It certainly seemed that the airborne fungus was related to the Central American smoke.
As a final demonstration that smoke can harbor fungal spores, Mims set fire to several different kinds of organic material and held Petrifilms out in the smoke to collect any spores that might be released. Smoke from fires made from live grass, dead grass, flood debris, dry leaves, dry twigs and even newspaper released fungal spores that colonized the Petrifilms. Each sample showed lots more fungal growth than the reference filmsfilms exposed to plain airtaken before, after, and in between each of the experimental burns. Clearly, fires dont destroy all kinds of fungal spores, and those spores can be released in a fires smoke.
I think thats a fascinating possibility, says Gene Shinn, a scientist with the U.S. Geological Surveys Coastal and Marine Geology Program, based in Florida. Shinn and his colleagues have been culturing bacteria from African Dust blowing over the Caribbean for many years, linking the decline of Caribbean coral reefs in the 1970s, 80s, and 90s to bacterial infections brought over the sea with Saharan dust. While the air samples they collect almost always contain some bacteria that have hitched a ride across the Atlantic on the dust particles, Shinn says the presence or absence of fungi is unpredictable.
Sometimes there are fungi in the samples, and sometimes not. We really had no idea why this was the case. We never considered smoke as a possibility, but there is periodic widespread biomass burning that takes places in the African Congo, and that smoke could be coming across the Atlantic mixed with dust. Here in Florida, we also get a lot of the smoke from fires in Central America. We have felt all along there had to be some additional factor explaining the fungi, and its intriguing to think this could be it.
The possibility of the microbes traveling with the smoke isnt farfetched, says Shinn. That dark smoke will act as an ultraviolet shield for the fungi, protecting them from UV damage. Even if the spores went high into the atmosphere, its quite possible they could remain sufficiently protected from the Suns ultraviolet rays to still be viable when they come back to Earth.
The presence of viable fungal spores in smoke certainly raises the possibility that burning pastures, crops, and trees that are infected with fungal diseases might not be a good idea. Such burning is practiced all over the world. If spores are released in smoke, diseases could spread as far as the smoke does.
On the other hand, many kinds of fungi are beneficialeven essentialfor vegetation. They recycle nutrients into the soil by decomposing dead vegetation. Certain plants and trees have developed a partnership with fungi that infect their roots, with each one providing the other with nutrients that the other cant get on its own (or cant get as well), while doing each other no harm. If spores from these beneficial soil fungi could escape the reach of the flames with smoke and then settle back down after the fire dies back, they might speed up the recovery of the burnedlandscape.
A Scientific Family
That such an important discovery has been made by a high school student provides a wonderful contrast to the rather depressing statistics about the decline in scores of American students on standardized science and math tests that we hear so much about. Mims is the kind of student who gives us reason to believe there is hope for another generation of promisingscientists.
In the Mims household, science is a family activity, with Sarahs dad as the instigator. Himself an amateur scientist, Forrest Mims passion for tinkering with electronics and science equipment led to a career writing books and designing electronics and science kits for Radio Shack. Amateur became professional, though, when a homemade device he built provided ground-based feedback about the accuracy of one of the first satellite sensors NASA launched to monitor the ozone layer. Since then, he has been involved in several NASA projects, including studies of smoke, ozone, and ultraviolet radiation in the Amazon. Hes also one of the lead scientists in NASAs GLOBE program, a worldwide, hand-on science education program, in which students collect Earth science observations and analyze them in conjunction withscientists.
Having a scientist for a father clearly motivated Sarah and her older brother and sister. Sarahs older brother Eric developed a seismometer that detected two underground nuclear tests in Nevada from his bedroom back home in Texas, and her sister Vicki measured the rotation of the sun by tracking sunspots. As far back as first or second grade, Forrest Mims was encouraging Sarah to conduct basic science experiments. She remembers that one of her first science projects was a science-in-your-home standard. The very first one I can remember doing was measuring the acidity of common household products. Every year I would take on a new project, she says.
As she grew up, she began to realize the practical advantages to her science projects. I like discovering new things about the world, and I like the challenge of answering questions from the scientists who judge the fairs, she says. She must have impressed quite a few of them because she has already been offered numerous college scholarships, and hopes to win more as a result of her senior year project, which is a follow-on to her pervious work.
I know that the weakest part of my last project is the possibility that the fungal spores are local, explains Mims. Even though the samples were collected on an observation tower that was 3 meters (about 10 feet) above the ground, and even though the spores did increase when smoke was present, its still possible, she says, that the spores she collected on her slides and her Petrifilms were local fungi stirred up from the ground. There could be some other reason why spores increased at the same time as the Central America smoke events. Perhaps the winds that drove the smoke north, for example, kicked up more spores than usual as the air traveled the short distance between Texas Gulf Coast and the town of Seguin.
Mims hopes her senior year project, carried out this summer, will provide conclusive evidence that Central American smoke is the source of the spores. To get the best evidence, she knew she needed to reduce as much as possible the chances that the spores were from other places in Texas. She needed to collect samples as close to the open waters of the Gulf of Mexico as possible, and high up in the air. To solve the first problem, she chose to collect samples at Padre Island, on the Texas coast.
To solve the second problem, she followed in her fathers creative footsteps, making her own low-tech device for collecting samples. Mims hesitates a little as she describes it, as though shes afraid it wont sound very scientific. I took a plastic cup and cut holes in the rim, where you drink, and then attached it to the kite with string. Then I pressed my microscope slides into the bottom of thecup.
It might seem low-tech, but it did the job, collecting plenty of good air samples. Well, except for the time when I quit paying attention for a second, and the kite dove into the ocean, she says, laughing. That was kind of a drag. I had to wipe everything off and start all over.
In the summer of 2003, Mims began analyzing the two main kite samples and found both spores and soot. The NOAA back-trajectories show that the air over Padre Island the day she was flying her kite had originated in the Yucatan two days earlier, where plenty of fires were burning. These latest observationscollected far from land and way up in the aironce again show a link between smoke and spores, making Mims a lot more confident that many of the spores she has been collecting are coming with the smoke, and not from local sources. Her amazing discovery is sure to be the start of this young scientists promisingcareer.
References: Sarah A. Mims and Forrest M. Mims III, Fungal spores are transported long distances in smoke from biomass fires, Atmospheric Environment 38, 651-655 (2004).
Abstract: Fungal spores are transported long distances in smoke from biomass fires
Viable fungal spores are present in smoke from distant biomass fires. This finding has potentially important implications for prescribed burning, agricultural management and public health. While attempting to find fungal spores in dust blown from China to Texas, one of us (S.A.M.) discovered that smoke from Yucatan contains viable bacteria and fungal spores, including the genera Alternaria, Cladosporium, Fusariella and Curvularia. There was a high correlation (r2=0.78) of spores and coarse carbon particles collected on microscope slides during 13 days of the 2002 smoke season. To eliminate possible contamination by local spores, an air sampler was flown from a kite at a Texas Gulf Coast beach during and after the 2003 smoke season on days when the NOAA back trajectory showed air arriving from Yucatan. Fifty-two spores and 19 coarse black carbon particles (>2.5 small mu, Greekm) were collected during a 30-min kite flight on the smoke day and 12 spores and four carbons on the day without smoke. We have found spores in smoke from an Arizona forest fire and in Asian smoke at Mauna Loa Observatory, Hawaii. We have tested these findings by burning dried grass, leaves, twigs and flood detritus. The smoke from all test fires contained many spores.
Author Keywords: Prescribed fires; Agricultural fires; Public health; Carbon; Dust